Newton's Flaming Laser Sword, known more blandly as Alder's Razor is another philosophical razor. Essentially, it states that if something can't be easily observed or proven through testing and experimentation, it is not valid or worth discussion. This means that if we say something, we better be able to back it up with proof or action.
In construction, this razor often applies in change order or claim situations. In these situations, contractors the initial burden of proof is often on the contractor or subcontractor or vendor. First to show that a change occurred and second to prove or justify the additional compensation requested. The client or GC must then review the request for compliance with the contract and for proof that additional compensation is required. They must then take a position that should be easily understood or proven through contract terms and project conditions. When logic and understanding is applied by all project team members, this process can progress pretty quickly through back and forth discussions and adjustments.
Sometimes, it can apply to shutdown or MOPO work. This kind of work usually requires strict and tight schedules and completion timeframes. Running long can cost facilities millions of dollars, keep roads closed into rush hour, restrict water supply and more. Ever confident, contractors will promise to meet tight schedules, plan details diligently and plan to figure everything else out. Observance of simple production rates and historical performance on similar scopes of past work can be used to verify plans and team member statements.
When confronted with statements or positions that seem a little far fetched, we can be a bit blunt with our response. When presented with complex or fancy proposals or solutions, we can simply say prove it or show me. Making things simple isn't always so simple but in most cases, real solutions and proposals can be easily and transparently proven. The more we make our plans and positions observable and provable, the more we can build a better world.
Commenti